New York landlord-tenant laws establish important rights and responsibilities for residential landlords and tenants. These laws address leases, rent, security deposits, property conditions, privacy, discrimination and eviction procedures. Additional rules may apply based on the location of the property, whether the apartment is rent regulated and whether a local government has adopted additional tenant protections.
Because commercial tenancies are governed by different rules, this article focuses primarily on residential rental property. At Cole, Sorrentino, Hurley, Hewner & Gambino, P.C., our attorneys help landlords and tenants understand their legal rights and address disputes involving New York rental property.
The Lease Agreement and Its Importance
A lease establishes the terms under which a tenant may occupy a rental property. It commonly addresses the rent, duration of the tenancy, security deposit, utilities, maintenance responsibilities, permitted occupants, pets and other property rules.
Some residential tenancies can be created orally. However, an agreement to lease real property for more than one year generally must be in writing to satisfy New York’s Statute of Frauds. Even when an oral agreement may be legally recognized, a written lease provides clearer evidence of the parties’ obligations.
Residential leases must be written clearly, and certain rights cannot be waived. For example, a residential lease cannot validly waive the warranty of habitability or excuse a landlord from liability for the landlord’s negligence. Landlords and tenants should carefully review the complete lease before signing it.
Rent, Late Fees and Renewal Notices
Tenants must pay the rent required by the lease. For most residential tenancies, rent cannot be treated as late until it has remained unpaid for more than five days after the due date. A residential late fee generally cannot exceed $50 or 5% of the monthly rent, whichever is less.
For a non-rent-regulated tenancy, a landlord proposing a rent increase of more than 5% or declining to renew generally must provide advance written notice. The required notice is ordinarily:
- Thirty days when the tenant has occupied the property for less than one year and does not have a lease term of at least one year
- Sixty days when the tenant has occupied the property for more than one but less than two years
- Ninety days when the tenant has occupied the property for at least two years or has a lease term of at least two years
These notice periods do not necessarily give an unregulated tenant a right to renewal. Rent-regulated apartments and housing covered by the Good Cause Eviction Law may be subject to additional renewal and rent-increase protections.
Tenant Rights and Responsibilities
Every written or oral residential lease in New York includes a warranty of habitability. This generally means that the premises must be safe, sanitary, fit for human habitation and free from conditions that are dangerous or detrimental to the occupants’ life, health or safety.
Landlords are responsible for addressing covered conditions such as persistent failures to provide heat or hot water, serious plumbing or electrical problems, dangerous structural conditions and qualifying pest infestations. The applicable housing code and required services may vary by municipality and type of property.
Tenants should report repair problems promptly and preserve written communications, photographs and other records. A tenant may have remedies when a landlord breaches the warranty of habitability, including asking a court for a rent abatement. A rent-regulated tenant may also be able to file a service-reduction complaint with the Division of Housing and Community Renewal.
A tenant may withhold rent and assert a breach of the warranty of habitability in response to a nonpayment case. However, withholding rent can result in the landlord filing an eviction proceeding, and the amount of any reduction is not automatically determined by the tenant. A tenant considering withholding rent or deducting repair expenses should obtain legal advice about the risks and proper procedure.
Tenants must comply with lawful lease terms, pay rent, avoid creating a nuisance and refrain from intentionally or negligently damaging the property. Tenants generally are not responsible for ordinary wear and tear.
Landlord Rights and Responsibilities
Landlords have the right to collect lawful rent, enforce valid lease provisions, obtain appropriate access to the property and begin a court proceeding when a legal basis for eviction exists.
Landlords must also maintain covered rental properties in compliance with applicable health, safety and housing requirements. They may not retaliate against protected tenants for making good-faith complaints about unsafe conditions, asserting rights under a lease or law, or participating in a tenant organization.
Landlord Entry and Tenant Privacy
Tenants have a right to privacy in their homes. A landlord may generally enter with reasonable prior notice, at a reasonable time and with the tenant’s consent to perform routine or agreed-upon repairs, provide services or exercise a right of entry established by the lease.
If a tenant unreasonably refuses necessary access, the landlord may seek a court order. In an emergency, such as a fire, active water leak or other immediate danger, a landlord may enter without advance notice or consent.
Related Videos
Why Do You Need a Real Estate Broker?
Attorney Approval Process
Security Deposits
A residential security deposit is generally limited to one month’s rent. The deposit remains the tenant’s money and must be held in trust rather than mixed with the landlord’s personal funds. Additional banking and interest requirements may apply, including for properties containing six or more dwelling units.
A landlord may generally use a security deposit for lawful purposes such as unpaid rent, damage beyond ordinary wear and tear, certain unpaid utility charges payable directly to the landlord, or reasonable moving and storage expenses resulting from the tenancy.
For non-rent-regulated units, the landlord generally must return the remaining deposit and provide an itemized statement of any deductions within 14 days after the tenant vacates. Failure to provide the required statement within that period may cause the landlord to lose the right to retain any portion of the deposit. Different timing rules may apply to rent-regulated units.
Before a tenant moves in, the parties should be offered an opportunity to inspect the premises and document existing conditions. A tenant planning to move out may request a pre-move-out inspection and an opportunity to correct identified conditions before the tenancy ends, subject to the governing requirements.
The Eviction Process in New York
A landlord cannot lawfully evict a tenant by changing the locks, removing the tenant’s belongings, using threats or shutting off essential services. A legal eviction generally requires proper notice, a court proceeding, a judgment of possession and a warrant of eviction.
The notices required before filing depend on the type of case. Before commencing a residential nonpayment proceeding, a landlord generally must serve a written 14-day rent demand. Holdover proceedings involving an expired tenancy, lease violation or other grounds may require different termination, cure or predicate notices.
The tenant must be served with the court papers and has the opportunity to answer, raise defenses and appear before a judge. A tenant should never ignore an eviction notice or court papers.
Even after a landlord obtains a judgment and warrant, the landlord cannot personally carry out the eviction. Only an authorized sheriff, marshal or constable may execute the warrant after providing the legally required notice. A residential tenant ordinarily receives at least 14 days’ notice before execution of the warrant.
Good Cause Eviction Protections
New York’s Good Cause Eviction Law became effective in 2024. It applies in New York City and in municipalities outside New York City that choose to adopt it. The law does not cover every property or landlord.
When the law applies, a covered landlord generally needs a statutorily recognized good cause to evict a tenant or refuse renewal. It also provides procedures for challenging certain unreasonable rent increases. Covered and exempt landlords may have specific disclosure obligations in leases, renewal offers and legal notices.
Because local participation and exemptions can change, landlords and tenants should confirm whether the law applies to the particular property rather than assuming that every New York tenancy is covered.
Rent Control and Rent Stabilization
Rent control and rent stabilization limit lawful rents and provide additional protections concerning lease renewals, services and evictions. Coverage depends on the building, location, construction date, regulatory history and any applicable tax-benefit program.
In New York City, rent stabilization generally includes many buildings containing six or more apartments that were built before 1974. Some newer or substantially renovated buildings may also be regulated because they received certain tax benefits. Outside New York City, qualifying municipalities may adopt rent stabilization through the Emergency Tenant Protection Act after satisfying the statutory requirements.
Rent control generally applies to a more limited group of long-term tenancies. A tenant or owner who is uncertain about a unit’s status may request records or guidance from New York State Homes and Community Renewal. The age or size of a building alone does not always establish whether an apartment is regulated.
Resolving Landlord-Tenant Disputes
Many disputes begin with disagreements about rent, repairs, lease terms, security deposits or property damage. Important communications should be made in writing and supported by relevant documents, photographs, inspection reports, receipts and payment records.
Depending on the dispute, the parties may attempt negotiation or mediation. Tenants may also contact local code-enforcement or housing agencies about unsafe conditions, file an appropriate administrative complaint, bring a court proceeding or raise defenses and counterclaims in an existing case.
The appropriate procedure depends on the nature of the tenancy and dispute. Landlords must also carefully follow notice and service requirements because a case may be dismissed when the required steps are not completed correctly.
Fair Housing and Protection Against Discrimination
Federal, New York State and local fair-housing laws prohibit discrimination in the sale, rental and financing of housing. Protected characteristics under New York law include race, creed, color, national origin, citizenship or immigration status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, military status, sex, age, disability, marital status, familial status, lawful source of income and status as a victim of domestic violence. Certain exceptions may apply under specific laws.
Housing providers may also be required to provide reasonable accommodations or permit reasonable modifications for people with disabilities. Depending on the circumstances, this may include changing a rule or policy or allowing an assistance animal despite a general no-pet policy.
A person who believes housing discrimination occurred may be able to file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development or an applicable local human-rights agency. Filing deadlines apply, so prompt action is important.
Legal Support for Landlords and Tenants
New York landlord-tenant law varies based on the property, municipality, lease and regulatory status. A rule that applies to one apartment may not apply to another. Legal guidance can be especially important when a dispute involves an eviction notice, unsafe condition, substantial rent claim, security deposit, regulated apartment or alleged discrimination.
The attorneys at Cole, Sorrentino, Hurley, Hewner & Gambino, P.C. help clients understand leases, comply with required procedures and address residential and commercial real estate disputes. Contact us to discuss your landlord-tenant matter.

I reside in a private coop in the Bronx. The Board has chosen to raise the maintenance 25% on January 1,2025. Shareholders were invited to attend a board meeting via Zoom, but all shareholders were muted. We were told by the managing agent that we do not get a chance to vote or discuss the increase. We were also told that shareholders do not have a right to vote on which building projects are prioritize. We have petitioned to dissolve the board of directors for allowing the management company to take over our building. Most shareholders here live on fixed incomes and can not afford a 25% rent increase. Shareholders have made attempts to unite around the Board’s lack of transparency and the Management Company ‘s influence over board members. I was elected vice president, but I quit because neither the building’s President or secretary were operating under the proprietary lease and bylaws. The board refuses to meet without the management company . When shareholders complain to 311, we are retaliated against.The director of the management company refused to allow shareholders to meet in the conference room.The last meeting we conducted in the lobby and the secretary and president verbally harassed and threatened the shareholders. After the meeting, 2 other shareholders and I received an email from the managing agent threatening to take legal action against us. The President and Secretary also posted derogatory comments regarding the information that we presented to the shareholders that listed the responsibilities and rights of shareholders taken from the NYS Attorney General’s Office on social media, claiming that the information was false.