What is considered a wrongful foreclosure in New York State?

A wrongful foreclosure occurs when a lender attempts to foreclose without following the strict legal procedures required by New York law, or if the borrower has a valid legal defense. Common grounds include improper service of the foreclosure complaint, lack of 'standing' by the lender, significant mortgage servicing errors, or violation of federal consumer protection laws.

What is 'lack of standing' and how does it stop a foreclosure?

'Lack of standing' is a common defense where the borrower challenges the lender's legal right to foreclose. It means the plaintiff (the party suing) cannot prove they legally own the note and mortgage and therefore has no right to bring the lawsuit. If proven, the court must dismiss the foreclosure action.

What should I do immediately after receiving a foreclosure complaint in New York?

Your most immediate step is to contact an attorney experienced in foreclosure defense. You have a limited time (typically 20 or 30 days) to file a formal legal response called an 'Answer.' Failing to file an Answer allows the lender to seek a default judgment, which greatly limits your defense options.

How does the mandatory settlement conference work in New York foreclosure cases?

New York law requires a mandatory settlement conference for all residential foreclosures involving owner-occupied homes. This is a court-supervised meeting where both parties, with their attorneys, attempt to negotiate a resolution, such as a loan modification, forbearance agreement, or short sale, before the case proceeds to litigation.

Can a loan modification be a solution for a wrongful foreclosure case?

Yes, often the goal of fighting a wrongful foreclosure is to compel the lender to offer a sustainable loan modification. While the lawsuit proceeds, successful defense strategies can give the homeowner leverage to negotiate new terms, lower interest rates, or extend the repayment period, ultimately allowing them to keep their home.

What are the risks of representing myself in a New York foreclosure case?

The New York foreclosure process is governed by strict, complex statutes (CPLR) and court rules. Representing yourself (pro se) significantly increases the risk of losing your case on a technicality, missing critical deadlines, or failing to raise sophisticated legal defenses like lack of standing or servicing errors, ultimately leading to the loss of your home.

How to Handle a Wrongful Foreclosure Case in New York

Dealing with the threat of foreclosure is a stressful and often overwhelming experience. When you believe that the foreclosure process against you is wrongful, it is crucial to understand how to protect your home and what steps you can take. In New York, laws exist to ensure that homeowners are treated fairly during the foreclosure process. If these laws are violated, you may have a legal case to challenge the foreclosure. This guide will explain how you can handle a wrongful foreclosure case and what actions you should consider taking.

Richard H. Cole
Partner

Thomas F. Hewner
Partner

Donna L. Haslinger
Partner

Vivian P. Roche'
Partner

Keith R. Rosso
Attorney

Tasha D. Frazie
Attorney

Tyler I. Wood
Attorney

Marc A. Cangé
Attorney

Teresa M. Cappiello
Attorney

What Constitutes a Wrongful Foreclosure?

A wrongful foreclosure happens when a lender wrongfully claims the right to take your property. This could happen for a variety of reasons, such as mistakes made during the foreclosure process, failure to follow required procedures, or improper documentation. Some examples include errors in paperwork, failure to notify the homeowner about missing payments, or pursuing foreclosure while the homeowner is actively working on a loan modification or forbearance agreement. Sometimes, the lender may not even have the legal right to initiate the foreclosure in the first place.

Identifying the Cause of the Wrongful Foreclosure

It is essential to figure out why the foreclosure is being carried out wrongly. Start by reviewing your mortgage documents, any communication you have received from the lender, and the history of your payments.

Consulting with a Foreclosure Defense Attorney

The next step is to consult with a lawyer who handles foreclosure defense cases. A skilled attorney can examine the details of your mortgage, payment history, and the actions taken by the lender. They can advise you on whether there is a basis for a wrongful foreclosure claim and help you navigate the complex legal system. Your attorney can also help by filing motions to stop the foreclosure process, such as a motion to dismiss or an emergency injunction. These motions may delay the foreclosure proceedings while a court considers the case.

An attorney will also help you determine whether you can challenge the foreclosure by raising certain legal defenses, such as improper standing or violations of foreclosure procedures.

Richard Cole is the absolute best real estate attorney in WNY. I wouldn’t think of getting involved in a transaction without him. His knowledge, attention to detail, and constant communication make buying and selling a property so much easier. I have done several deals with him and will continue using his services in the future.

James F.

Challenging the Foreclosure in Court

Once a foreclosure lawsuit is filed, you will need to respond to the complaint within a specific time frame. If you fail to respond, the court may rule in favor of the lender. However, if the foreclosure is wrongful, you can challenge it in court by raising various legal defenses. For instance, you may be able to argue that the lender has not proven they have the legal right to foreclose or that they have failed to follow the proper procedures.

In New York, there are specific legal steps that lenders must follow to initiate and complete a foreclosure. If the lender fails to adhere to these steps, the foreclosure may be deemed wrongful. A lawyer can help you identify and argue these issues in court.

Requesting a Temporary Restraining Order or Injunction

In some cases, it may be possible to halt the foreclosure proceedings immediately by requesting a temporary restraining order (TRO) or injunction from the court. A TRO is an emergency measure that prevents the foreclosure from moving forward while the court evaluates the situation. If a foreclosure sale is scheduled, a TRO can stop the sale and give you time to contest the action.

Exploring Loan Modification or Mediation

If the foreclosure is due to missed payments, you may be able to explore alternatives such as a loan modification or mediation with the lender. New York offers a mediation program for homeowners facing foreclosure. This program allows homeowners and lenders to meet with a neutral third party to discuss the possibility of modifying the loan or reaching an agreement that prevents foreclosure.

A loan modification might involve reducing the interest rate, extending the term of the loan, or even forgiving part of the loan balance. If you are negotiating a loan modification, the foreclosure process may be paused while the lender reviews your case. It is important to communicate with the lender during this time and ensure that they are not moving forward with foreclosure while you are seeking a resolution.

Considering a Lawsuit Against the Lender

If the lender refuses to stop the foreclosure despite valid legal defenses or violations, you may have the option to file a lawsuit against them. Homeowners sometimes file lawsuits against lenders for issues such as breach of contract, violations of consumer protection laws, or fraud. If you believe that the lender has wrongfully initiated or pursued foreclosure, your lawyer can help you pursue legal action to stop it and potentially seek compensation.

This step is often considered a last resort, but it is sometimes necessary when all other options have been exhausted.

Exploring Your Options After Foreclosure

If the court rules against you and the foreclosure proceeds, there are still options available. In New York, you may be able to redeem your home after the foreclosure sale by paying off the full amount owed. This process is known as “equity of redemption” and typically applies within a certain time frame after the sale. However, the rules around redemption can be complex, and it is critical to work with an attorney to explore this possibility.

Additionally, you may face a deficiency judgment if the home is sold for less than what is owed on the mortgage. In this case, the lender could try to collect the remaining balance from you. If this happens, you may be able to negotiate a settlement or explore bankruptcy as a way to eliminate or reduce your debt.

A wrongful foreclosure in New York can be complicated, but there are steps you can take to fight back and protect your home. From understanding the reasons for the wrongful foreclosure to working with an attorney and exploring alternatives like loan modifications or mediation, there are ways to potentially stop the process. By acting quickly and consulting with a knowledgeable lawyer, you can navigate the legal system and explore your options.

At Cole, Sorrentino, Hurley, Hewner & Gambino, P.C., we understand the pressure that comes with foreclosure proceedings and are dedicated to helping homeowners protect their rights. Contact us today for a consultation, and let us help you fight for your home.

Call For A Legal Consultation

(716) 869-3011

Foreclosure