“Guardian ad litem” is often used as a general term for someone who speaks for a child in a custody dispute. In New York, that shorthand can be misleading. A guardian ad litem and an attorney for the child are different court appointments with different duties. Knowing which role appears in your case helps you understand who the person represents and what the court has asked that person to do.
New York Courts explains the difference: guardians ad litem are most often used in Surrogate’s Court and are appointed for a particular case to report to the court and represent the interests of a child or person who cannot fully protect their own interests. Attorneys for the child, formerly called law guardians, advocate for children in Family Court matters and custody or visitation disputes. The appointment order matters more than a casual label.
Richard H. Cole
Partner
Thomas F. Hewner
Partner
Donna L. Haslinger
Partner
Keith R. Rosso
Attorney
Marc A. Cangé
Attorney
Teresa M. Cappiello
Attorney
What Does a Guardian ad Litem Do?
A guardian ad litem has a limited role in a specific proceeding. The assigned tasks depend on the law, the court, and the appointment order. In a Surrogate’s Court matter, the guardian ad litem may review papers, consider the interests of the person represented, and report findings to the court. The Surrogate’s Court rules address guardian ad litem reports and compensation. A guardian ad litem does not become a permanent guardian simply because of the appointment.
New York courts also use guardians ad litem in certain other proceedings involving people who need assistance protecting their interests during litigation. That possibility does not make a guardian ad litem the routine child advocate in every custody case. If a court mentions an appointment, ask to review the signed order and identify the court, the person represented, and the scope of the appointment.
How Is an Attorney for the Child Different?
In a custody or visitation case, a judge may appoint an attorney for the child. That lawyer represents the child as a client under the rules governing the appointment. The attorney is not simply a neutral investigator working for either parent. New York Courts expressly distinguishes this advocate from a guardian ad litem. Its Guardian and Fiduciary Services page lists the roles separately.
Parents should also distinguish the attorney for the child from each parent’s own lawyer. Each attorney has a different client and professional responsibility. If you receive a notice of appointment, your lawyer can explain what the appointed professional may do, what information you may need to provide, and how the child’s privacy and the court’s directions affect communication.
Appointments in Custody and Family-Related Cases
A custody case may involve an attorney for the child, a guardian ad litem in a particular circumstance, or no such appointment. A New York matrimonial court’s preliminary conference form contemplates consideration of whether an attorney for the child or guardian ad litem is needed and states that an appointment is made through a separate order. The form also calls for the order to identify payment responsibility.
The type of case and the appointment order determine the professional’s role. A generic online description cannot substitute for reviewing the actual court order.
In Surrogate’s Court, a guardian ad litem may be appointed to protect a minor’s interest in an estate proceeding. This is a distinct setting from a dispute over a parenting schedule. The court’s explanation of guardians, guardians ad litem, and attorneys for the child is a useful starting point when a family is unsure which role is involved.
What Should a Parent Do After an Appointment?
Start by obtaining the signed appointment order and asking your attorney to explain its scope. Keep relevant records organized, respond truthfully to appropriate requests, and follow court directions concerning communication.
If a report or recommendation concerns you, identify the specific facts you believe are incomplete or incorrect and discuss with your attorney the proper way to present that information to the judge. The appointed professional’s position does not replace the court’s final decision.
Questions about fees also depend on the appointment order and applicable court rules. Do not assume that every guardian ad litem or attorney for the child is compensated in the same way. The matrimonial form cited above calls for the payment source and each party’s responsibility to be stated in the appointment order.
Related Videos
Choosing a Divorce Attorney
First Step of the Divorce Process
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Guardian ad Litem the Same as an Attorney for the Child?
No. New York Courts describes these as different appointments. An attorney for the child advocates for a child in Family Court and custody matters. A guardian ad litem is appointed for a particular proceeding to protect the interests of a child or person who cannot fully protect their own interests and is most often used in Surrogate’s Court.
How Is a Guardian ad Litem Appointed in New York?
The court makes the appointment by order when the law and circumstances call for one. The appointment order and applicable court rules define the person represented, the appointed professional’s responsibilities, and the scope of the role.
Who Pays for a Guardian ad Litem?
There is no single payment rule for every proceeding. The court order may address the source of payment and each party’s responsibility. Review the specific appointment order before assuming who will pay.
Can I Question a Guardian ad Litem’s Report or Recommendation?
A guardian ad litem does not make the judge’s final decision. If you dispute a report or recommendation, speak with your attorney about the applicable procedure for presenting evidence, correcting factual errors, or raising concerns with the court.
Does Every New York Custody Case Have a Guardian ad Litem?
No. Many custody matters proceed without a guardian ad litem. A court may instead appoint an attorney for the child in an appropriate custody case. The two roles should not be treated as interchangeable.
Discuss Your New York Family Law Case
If you have received a notice of appointment, are involved in a custody dispute, or want to understand who represents your child, our Buffalo child custody attorneys can review the papers and explain the next step.
Cole, Sorrentino, Hurley, Hewner & Gambino, P.C. can also help you distinguish an attorney for the child from a guardian ad litem before you respond to an appointment order or report. Contact us to discuss your circumstances. No particular result can be promised.