When Can a Child Decide Which Parent to Live With in NY?

If you are visiting our page, you are likely dealing with an emotional and confusing time in your life. Child custody issues can make any parent feel overwhelmed, especially when they involve the wishes of a child.

You may be wondering when your child can decide which parent to live with in New York. There is no specific age at which a child can make that decision independently. The court may consider the child’s wishes, but the judge must ultimately determine what custody arrangement serves the child’s best interests.

At our firm, we want you to know that you are not alone. We understand how important your child’s future is, and we are prepared to help guide you through the legal process.

How Custody Decisions Are Made in New York

When parents cannot agree on a custody arrangement, the court makes its decision based on the best interests of the child. The child’s health and safety are paramount concerns, but the judge will consider the family’s circumstances as a whole.

The court will not decide custody based solely on which parent the child says they want to live with. The child’s preference is one factor among many considered by the judge.

Is There an Age When a Child Can Choose?

In New York, there is no fixed age at which a child can choose which parent to live with. A child does not automatically gain the right to decide upon turning 12, 14, 16, or any other age before adulthood.

However, the child’s age and maturity can affect how much weight the court gives to their preference. A clearly expressed preference from a mature older teenager may receive substantial consideration. A younger child’s views may also be considered, but the court will evaluate the child’s ability to understand the situation and whether someone may have influenced the preference.

Even when an older teenager expresses a strong preference, the judge retains the authority to issue the custody arrangement that the judge determines is in the child’s best interests.

What the Court Considers When Listening to a Child

The judge may consider the reasons behind the child’s preference, the child’s age and maturity, and whether the child appears to have been coached or pressured.

A preference based primarily on having fewer rules or receiving more gifts may be evaluated differently from concerns involving the child’s safety, care, emotional well-being, education, or stability. Nevertheless, the court reviews the complete circumstances rather than relying on a single statement from the child.

The court may appoint an attorney for the child. This attorney represents the child and generally advocates for the child’s expressed position. In limited circumstances, such as when a child lacks the capacity for a knowing and voluntary position or following the child’s wishes would create a substantial risk of serious and imminent harm, different professional responsibilities may apply.

Age and Maturity Can Make a Difference

Courts frequently give greater weight to the views of older, more mature children. However, there is no rule establishing age 14 as the point when a child’s preference controls the case.

A judge will consider whether the child can clearly explain the preference, understands its consequences, and appears to be expressing an independent opinion. The court may still order a different arrangement if the evidence shows that the requested arrangement would not serve the child’s best interests.

Other Factors the Court May Consider

The child’s preference is only one part of the best-interests analysis. Depending on the case, the judge may also consider:

• Which parent has served as the child’s primary caregiver
• Each parent’s parenting abilities and past performance
• The quality and stability of each parent’s home environment
• Each parent’s physical and mental health
• Each parent’s work schedule and childcare arrangements
• The child’s educational, medical, emotional, and special needs
• The child’s relationships with siblings and other family members
• Whether there has been domestic violence, abuse, or neglect
• Each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent when doing so is safe

The court does not automatically favor one parent based on gender or financial resources alone. Its focus is the arrangement that will best protect and support the child.

Will the Child Have to Testify in Court?

A child will not necessarily be required to testify in an open courtroom. In some cases, the judge may speak privately with the child in chambers. This is commonly known as an in-camera interview or Lincoln hearing.

The parents and their attorneys generally do not attend this private interview or receive a complete account of what was discussed. This process allows the judge to learn about the child’s views while reducing the pressure and emotional stress that could result from questioning the child in front of the parents.

Whether to conduct such an interview depends on the circumstances of the case, including the child’s age and maturity and whether the interview is necessary to evaluate the child’s best interests.

Related Videos

What Happens if a Child Is Pressured to Choose?

The court may consider evidence that a parent has coached, pressured, or improperly influenced a child. Conduct intended to damage the child’s relationship with the other parent can negatively affect the court’s evaluation of that parent.

Parents should avoid questioning the child about the litigation, asking the child to carry messages, criticizing the other parent in the child’s presence, or making the child feel responsible for choosing between the parents.

Why Legal Representation Can Be Important

Custody cases can be difficult for parents and children. An experienced attorney can explain how the child’s wishes may fit into the court’s broader best-interests analysis and help present relevant evidence concerning the child’s care, safety, stability, and needs.

An attorney can also help you understand the roles of the judge and the attorney for the child, prepare for hearings, and pursue an arrangement that protects your parental rights and your child’s well-being.

How Long Can a Custody Case Take?

The length of a custody case depends on whether the parents reach an agreement, the complexity of the issues, the evidence required, and the court’s schedule. A negotiated agreement may be resolved more quickly, while a contested case involving hearings, evaluations, or numerous witnesses may take several months or longer.

The court may issue temporary custody or parenting-time orders while the case is pending. These temporary orders should be followed unless the court modifies them.

Can Parents Resolve Custody Without a Trial?

Parents may be able to negotiate a custody agreement with assistance from their attorneys. Mediation may also be available in appropriate cases. Any agreement should clearly address legal custody, the child’s primary residence, parenting schedules, holidays, transportation, and decision-making responsibilities.

Mediation may not be appropriate when domestic violence, coercion, a serious power imbalance, or child-safety concerns are present. An attorney can help you determine which process is appropriate for your family.

If the parents reach an agreement, the judge can review it and issue a custody order on consent. If they cannot agree, the judge will decide the disputed issues following a hearing.

We Are Here to Help You and Your Family

If you are facing a custody case and wondering when your child can decide which parent to live with in New York, every family’s situation is different. The child’s preference may be important, but it is not the only consideration and does not automatically control the outcome.

The attorneys at Cole, Sorrentino, Hurley, Hewner & Gambino, P.C. assist families with child custody and other family-law matters throughout Western New York. Contact our office to arrange a consultation and discuss your circumstances.

To learn more about this subject, read: The Top Mistakes to Avoid in a Child Custody Battle